top of page
Advocate-A-white-transparent.png

INTEGRITY IS A PRACTICE, NOT A PROMISE

Morgan McCarraher
2 days ago
3 min read

Integrity isn’t defined by the values we claim to hold, but by the choices we make when honesty, accountability and doing what’s right come at a personal cost.


Morgan McCarraher       The Advocate
Morgan McCarraher The Advocate

Integrity is an interesting thing. We admire it in others, expect it from our leaders and often claim it as one of our own defining qualities. We want to believe that we are honest people, that our principles mean something, and that when faced with a difficult decision, we will do what is right.


But how often are those beliefs actually tested?


It is easy to have integrity when there is nothing at stake. When honesty costs us nothing, when doing the right thing earns us praise, or when our principles happen to align with what everyone around us believes. In those moments, integrity requires very little of us.


The real test comes when doing the right thing becomes inconvenient. When telling the truth might damage a friendship. When admitting a mistake might cost us an opportunity. When standing by our principles means standing alone.


What do we do then?


We often describe integrity as doing the right thing even when no one is watching. There is truth in that, but perhaps it is an incomplete definition. Integrity is not simply about what we do in private. It is about whether the person we claim to be is the person our actions reveal. And sometimes, those two people are not the same. We all have values: honesty, fairness, kindness and accountability. They are easy words to say and even easier to put on a list.


But values are not particularly meaningful if we abandon them the moment they become uncomfortable.

Consider honesty. Most of us would say that lying is wrong. Yet how often do we justify a small lie because the truth would be inconvenient? We tell ourselves that it doesn’t really matter, that nobody was hurt, or that the situation was complicated.


Maybe it was. But if our principles only apply when following them is easy, are they really principles at all?


Of course, integrity does not mean perfection. We are human. We make mistakes, contradict ourselves, and occasionally fall short of the standards we set. Sometimes we discover that something we believed was right was actually wrong. There should be room for that.


In fact, I would argue that acknowledging our mistakes is one of the clearest demonstrations of integrity. It takes very little courage to defend ourselves when we are right. It takes considerably more to admit when we are wrong.


And perhaps that is where integrity becomes most difficult.


We live in a society that often rewards certainty over reflection. Changing our minds can be interpreted as weakness. Admitting fault can feel like surrender. Apologizing can seem like giving someone else the upper hand.


So we double down. We defend decisions we know were questionable. We search for explanations that make our actions seem reasonable, even when we know they weren’t. Not necessarily because we are dishonest people, but because being honest with ourselves can be uncomfortable.


Yet integrity demands exactly that. It asks us to examine the distance between our values and our behavior. To recognize when we have fallen short. To accept responsibility without immediately reaching for an excuse.


It also asks us to recognize that doing what is right may not always feel rewarding. Sometimes there is no recognition, no applause, and no one waiting to congratulate us. Sometimes doing the right thing simply means accepting a consequence we could have avoided.


Perhaps integrity is not something we possess, but something we practice.

A series of decisions, often small and unnoticed, that gradually determine the kind of person we become.


Because ultimately, integrity is not measured by the principles we proclaim when everyone is listening. It is measured by the principles we refuse to abandon when no one is watching.

Comments


bottom of page