THE COST OF ARTIFICIAL CREATIVITY
As generative AI becomes increasingly prevalent in creative industries, one student questions whether the pursuit of efficiency is worth the cost to human creativity, employment and resources.

What makes something valuable?
Does art created without the actual art of creation have a soul?
AI can’t replicate the heart at the center of an art piece. There’s a beauty to each mistake an artist makes and to how those mistakes make the artist better. Every individual stroke of a drawing has intention. Each piece of code in a game, every lyric in a song, they have heart. But not with AI. What AI produces is soulless imitation.
Every form of art has increasingly become polluted with generative AI. I believe that in trying to maximize efficiency, we have been killing artistic expression and growth. A learning curve makes the artist better and advances their skills, but AI eliminates that learning curve.
The accessibility and ease of use for AI-generated content have also given companies an excuse to stop hiring talented artists. Major companies and their owners have claimed that the use of AI could reduce human workloads, but it’s no stretch to see how it could also be an opportunity for employers to hire less and pay fewer salaries. Talented artists’ livelihoods are being threatened by machine learning systems trained on their work without their consent. Generative AI companies have used people’s content to improve their systems without permission, making an already scrutinized industry even more controversial.
When companies like Epic Games are proudly using AI to make games and are pushing veteran developers to adapt to AI, it scares me. Employers are more likely to choose the cheap machine over a human they have to pay a salary and benefits for.
What is the value in learning a skill if a machine can learn it and apply it instantly?
I believe artificial intelligence has value in some fields like medicine, science, translation and cybersecurity. In the art field, however, I believe it’s a cancer. If it continues to grow, an over-dependency on artificial intelligence will develop.
According to the College Board, 84% of high school students surveyed in May 2025 reported having used generative AI tools for schoolwork. The skills learned through experience are valuable, and if we let the next generations use AI as a crutch, these skills will never develop.
Artificial intelligence has a lot of potential for good, but I believe its current applications are not worth the costs.
Generative AI requires massive data centers to operate, and those data centers consume water and electricity our communities depend on.. So while our government is giving these companies large tax breaks, we face increasing electricity costs and diminishing job markets...
Where is the value of work generated without heart?
Art has never been just about a finished product. It’s about effort and heart and the experience of creating something that didn’t exist before.
Where is the integrity in utilizing something built on taking resources and
using the creative work of others without consent?
If the tradeoff for efficiency comes at the cost of human jobs, strained resources and increasing utility costs, what exactly have we gained?


Comments